My partner and I are leaving on a year long sailing trip this weekend. One of the last things on our shopping list is a spare handheld marine VHF radio. This spare radio will allow us to communicate with other boats if our main radio is incapacitated.
Canadian Tire’s website returned a few entries with the query “VHF Marine Radio” so I headed off to my local store.

When I arrived however I discovered that none of Canadian Tire’s radios were VHF Marine, they were all Walkie Talkies. This is problematic as Walkie Talkies can not communicate with VHF Marine Radios. Canadian Tire… more like Canadian Liar… amirite?
This may seem like an inconsequential mistake until you consider when these radios are likely to be used. In an emergency on the water; Walkie Talkies are as useless as a knitted life raft. Ideally humans will check their equipment before they use them, however these radios normally come as a pair. It would be easy to be lulled into a false sense of security after a successful self radio check.
Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity - Hanlon’s razor
It was unlikely that Canadian Tire was trying to trick people into floating powerless boats over waterfalls.

It far more likely that users of their website inadvertently trained Canadian Tire’s search algorithms into believing that “VHF Marine Radio” was a synonym for “Walkie Talkie”. A simple mistake for a gullible algorithm. Nowadays machine learning is relatively easy, machine learning useful things is more difficult. We’re likely to see more mistakes like this as algorithms penetrate our lives. I just hope the machines are smarter before they attempt their inevitable coup d’etat.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256
- ---
title: "VHF Maroon Radio"
description: "Canadian Tire's search algorithm confused walkie talkies with VHF marine radios. A cautionary tale about gullible ML."
image: /wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Canadian Tire VHF Marine Radio Search.png
author: Greg
layout: post
permalink: /2017/08/vhf-maroon-radio/
date: 2017-08-30 16:01:29 -0400
comments: True
licence: Creative Commons
categories:
- technology
tags:
- ai
- sailing
search_terms: [machine learning, artificial intelligence, search engine, search results, site search, ecommerce, e-commerce, online shopping, retail, handheld radio, handheld, two-way radio, spare radio, radio check, marine safety, boating safety, emergency, safety equipment, life raft, hanlon's razor, malice, stupidity, canadian liar, pun, fat cat rowing a boat, cat gif, boat, year long sailing trip, partner, svcatsaway, robot uprising]
- ---
My partner and I are leaving on a [year long sailing trip](https://www.youtube.com/SVCatsaway) this weekend. One of the last things on our shopping list is a spare handheld marine VHF radio. This spare radio will allow us to communicate with other boats if our main radio is incapacitated.
Canadian Tire's website returned a few entries with the query "VHF Marine Radio" so I headed off to my local store.
{:height="75%" width="75%"}
When I arrived however I discovered that none of Canadian Tire's radios were *VHF Marine*, they were all *Walkie Talkies*. This is problematic as Walkie Talkies can not communicate with VHF Marine Radios. Canadian Tire... more like Canadian Liar... amirite?
This may seem like an inconsequential mistake until you consider when these radios are likely to be used. In an emergency on the water; Walkie Talkies are as useless as a knitted life raft. Ideally humans will check their equipment before they use them, however these radios normally come as a pair. It would be easy to be lulled into a false sense of security after a successful self radio check.
***Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity - Hanlon's razor***
It was unlikely that Canadian Tire was trying to trick people into floating powerless boats over waterfalls.
{:height="75%" width="75%"}
It far more likely that users of their website inadvertently trained Canadian Tire's search algorithms into believing that "VHF Marine Radio" was a synonym for "Walkie Talkie". A simple mistake for a gullible algorithm. Nowadays machine learning is relatively easy, machine learning useful things is more difficult. We're likely to see more mistakes like this as algorithms penetrate our lives. I just hope the machines are smarter before they attempt their inevitable coup d'etat.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----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=LsYA
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----